The myth of a powerful finance ministry – Lifestyle News

India’s Finance Ministers: Stumbling into Reforms (1977-1998)

AK Bhattacharya

Penguin Random Home

Pp 536, Rs 999

There may be typically debate on whether or not economics drives politics or politics trumps economics. The second quantity on Indian finance ministers by AKB, because the writer is nicely generally known as, helps one determine to some extent. Whereas economics drives politics to an extent, the reverse relation is stronger.

A standard remark that pervades each the volumes is that the FM will not be an impartial particular person or entity. Typically, we are inclined to say that sure FMs did a greater job when presenting budgets relative to others. However what AKB reveals on this e-book, which is as attention-grabbing as the primary, is that every one selections are centralised with the prime minister. Any main transfer that’s introduced by the FM within the Finances is motivated by the PM. And the FM does probably not have a selection even when there’s a considerable amount of discomfort with the choice. Not surprisingly, Sardar Patel may do nothing on demonetisation, which then prime minister Morarji Desai was eager on.

We additionally get to know that RBI governor KR Puri needed to give up in 1977 as a result of he was a part of the Indira Gandhi institution and didn’t discover favour with the brand new authorities of Morarji Desai. Therefore politics had affect on the appointment and tenure of the RBI governor way back to the Seventies. A lot later within the day, governor RN Malhotra resigned in 1990 forward of his time period, as his recommendation in opposition to excessive authorities expenditure to the Yashwant Sinha-led finance ministry was not acquired favourably.

One other well-known ideological battle was the one between deputy governor YV Reddy of RBI and FM P Chidambaram. The 2 differed on the tempo of rupee ‘depreciation’ that was invoked by RBI, a lot to the chagrin of the FM through the Asian disaster in 1997. The FM had mentioned in a peeved method to the RBI deputy governor: “You’ll by no means be forgiven for what you could have achieved!”

We additionally get to know the interference of Indira Gandhi’s sons in points pertaining to the FM on this interval. R Venkataraman didn’t get together with Sanjay Gandhi, whereas Pranab Mukherjee had a tough time with Rajiv Gandhi after they have been finance ministers. Due to this fact, we get the message that being an FM will not be straightforward, though it’s the strongest ministry as that is the place all income of the federal government flows in and selections are taken on spend it.

Apparently, whereas lots of appreciation has gone in for the GST, which was launched extra just lately, the germination was from an thought sown three a long time earlier. The idea of a value-added tax had its origins within the mid-Eighties when VP Singh was FM. It got here within the type of MODVAT or modified worth added tax. Additional, the fiscal duty and price range administration that we speak of right now had its origins within the Eighties within the type of a long run fiscal coverage (LTFP), which although completely different in scope, had a imaginative and prescient for budgeting. Whereas that might be the excessive level of VP Singh’s tenure, the low level was when the FM went after the business for tax evasion. It appeared the FM was after Reliance Industries, which didn’t go down nicely with the Rajiv Gandhi authorities.

These anecdotes make the somewhat voluminous e-book an attention-grabbing learn. There are lots of info positioned on the desk and one can get to learn about all of the reforms that have been introduced in underneath completely different regimes. On condition that the interval was fairly tumultuous, the e-book additionally reveals the undercurrents that drove these reforms, which is probably not well-known to the reader.

Whereas the conventional narrative on financial reforms begins with Manmohan Singh underneath the management of Narasimha Rao, the writer factors out that almost all concepts on reforms really prevailed within the workplace of Yashwant Sinha, who was the FM for a brief tenure when Chandrashekhar was PM. Extra importantly, the reforms agenda was a fallout of the state of the financial system. The close to insolvency of the nation drove the federal government to the IMF for assist, and reforms have been a situation positioned that needed to be applied to attract the mortgage.

Whereas Manmohan Singh takes credit score for financial reforms, his tenure was additionally turbulent with the inventory market rip-off involving Harshad Mehta. The writer elaborates extra on the somewhat notorious assertion made by the FM on ‘not dropping sleep’ when the inventory market went down. One other clue one picks up is that when reforms have been in, there was actually no going again. Even whereas minority bubble governments got here and went, the FMs involved drove the reforms agenda, albeit at completely different speeds.

Therefore, one can say {that a} collection of reforms have been introduced in from the mid-Eighties. To start with, they have been gradual as a result of shifting from a completely regulated set as much as a extra liberal structure may solely be achieved in steps. Subsequently, the push got here from what one can interpret because the IMF nudging for giant bang reforms within the Nineties. Apparently, whereas the writer does convey out the completely different political ideologies on this interval of just about 15 years ending 1997, alignment with progressive insurance policies was at all times there. It additionally exhibits that progressive fiscal regimes can have mortgage waivers and money handouts, which is as a result of political financial system in motion.

The second quantity of India’s FMs relies on a time interval nearer to a bigger a part of the inhabitants right now and can be of nice curiosity to the layman in addition to researchers. The pure line of curiosity can be to attend for the writer’s third quantity, which hopefully will cowl the FMs until 2023-24. The questions that will be of utmost curiosity can be whether or not FMs are extra impartial than their predecessors, contemplating that there have been a number of reforms undertaken like demonetisation or the Covid insurance policies that have been routed extra by the financial and never fiscal prisms. The reader can be desirous to learn extra about these modern instances.

Madan Sabnavis is chief economist, Financial institution of Baroda