In relation to the trillion mysteries saved throughout the magical world of Harry Potter, nearly all have been answered within the novels and movies or else solved by its famend writer, J.Ok. Rowling. That stated, there are nonetheless some questions which have maintained their secret standing such that even the cinematic diversifications of the books didn’t attempt to clear up them.
Undoubtedly, one of many greatest baffling questions of all time facilities round why on earth Harry dropped the Resurrection Stone within the Forbidden Forest.
When did Harry Potter drop the Resurrection Stone?
The occasion takes place in direction of the top of the final ebook and movie within the sequence, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, the place Harry decides to sacrifice himself to kill Voldemort’s Horcrux inside him and save everybody’s lives. Whereas strolling by means of the Forbidden Forest (on his method to the Darkish Lord), Harry cracks Dumbledore’s code for unsealing the Golden Snitch and manages to get the Resurrection Stone saved inside it.
He then proceeds to make use of the Resurrection Stone to momentarily reunite with the spirits of his dad and mom, his godfather, and Remus Lupin. They supply him with the braveness he must voluntarily stroll as much as his nemesis and willingly settle for demise. However simply as he’s about to face Voldemort, he permits the stone to slide from his fingers, the place it joins the 1000’s of others on the forest ground, after which all of the spirits round him vanish.
Was Harry involved that Voldemort would see the spirits round him? No, as a result of it has been clarified that nobody who has used the stone to summon their deceased family members can see them. So why did he drop it?
Harry was by no means power-hungry like Voldemort
Voldemort was by no means in spite of everything three Deathly Hallows ⏤ he simply needed the Elder Wand, as he sought to turn into essentially the most highly effective wizard to be able to beat Harry. However, any true Harry Potter fan is aware of that the younger wizard by no means craved energy like his archenemy. In reality, he was sort, courageous, and able to struggle for what was proper.
He by no means had any need to dominate others. Regardless of figuring out the infinite energy the three Hallows would convey him (whereas already possessing the Invisibility Cloak), Harry as an alternative selected to proceed trying to find the Horcruxes.
The truth that he by no means harbored any need to own the Hallows was additional burdened within the movie, the place after the battle, he proceeds to interrupt the Elder Wand in half and throw it into the chasm beneath. The identical goes for the stone; he by no means even remotely entertained the notion of possessing it.
Additionally, whereas the one uniting the three Hallows can be referred to as the Grasp of Dying, Harry actually deserved the title. It was not as a result of he lastly had all three Hallows, however moderately as a result of he embraced demise head-on, with out being afraid of it, that he mastered it ⏤ in contrast to Voldemort, who created the Horcruxes to thrust back his inevitable finish.
Harry didn’t need Voldemort getting the Stone
When Harry bravely walked as much as face Voldemort, he had no concept that the Killing Curse would solely goal the a part of the Darkish Lord’s soul inside his physique. He actually thought that there was no manner out for him and he didn’t need Voldemort or his evil cronies to get their arms on the stone. So he hid it one of the simplest ways he might within the brief time he had: by dropping it amidst similar-looking bizarre stones.
The Darkish Lord by no means knew he had the stone; he was all the time after the Elder Wand and by no means actually grasped the idea of turning into the Grasp of Dying. However even then, had he survived and deliberate to seek for the stone, he doubtless by no means would have thought to search for it within the forest. Even when he did, because the stone doesn’t look very totally different from others you may discover within the woods, Harry couldn’t have discovered a greater hiding place for it.
Harry understood the stone’s illusions
We’re all accustomed to the story of the three brothers and the way the Hallows got here into existence. Whereas all three Hallows have been made by Dying, the stone and the wand have been a results of the primary two brothers’ greed, vanity, lust for energy, and need to trump Dying itself. The Resurrection Stone was extra harmful than the Elder Wand.
Whereas the latter served to amp up the greed of energy in these wanting the wand, the stone offered a watered-down phantasm of whoever the person needed to see. It taunted them with their unmet need and people who by no means understood it have been pushed to excessive measures, just like the second brother within the story who killed himself to be together with his lifeless lover.
Harry all the time remembered Dumbledore’s educating that “it doesn’t do to dwell on desires, and neglect to stay.” When he met Dumbledore after his “demise” by way of the Killing Curse, the Headmaster lauded him for letting the stone stay misplaced within the Forbidden Forest. He knew that Harry had craved the presence of his family members all his life, however regardless of that, he made the “sensible and brave resolution” to not go in search of the stone once more.
He knew that what the Stone introduced again was not actual ⏤ they have been merely shadows of people that had already moved on way back. He understood that one of the best he might do for the folks he beloved wouldn’t be to summon them once more, however to stay his life to the fullest.
It was actually not a sequel-creating transfer
Many followers have puzzled whether or not Harry dropping the Resurrection Stone was J.Ok. Rowling’s manner of leaving a gap for a sequel, the place will probably be used to convey again Voldemort or can be found by one other baddie to create extra chaos. For starters, Harry dropping the stone was solely added to represent his standing as a real, selfless hero.
As for Voldemort’s return, we’ve got already defined how the Stone can by no means convey somebody again to life. Earlier, in Goblet of Fireplace, he managed to come back again to life due to his Horcruxes, and even then it took years.
In reality, You Know Who, whose soul was already past broken because it had been torn a number of occasions to create the Horcruxes, can be an particularly troublesome soul to summon, neglect bringing him again to life.
As for the Resurrection Stone being found by one other villain in a potential future Harry Potter sequel, Rowling has personally squashed the situation. Throughout a stay webchat with followers again in 2007, she clarified that the stone won’t ever be discovered once more, because it was “squashed into the bottom by a centaur’s hoof because the centaurs dashed to the help of the Hogwarts fighters, and thereafter grew to become buried.”